Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.

Tempe agrees to $2 million settlement over police shooting of 14 year old

Antonio Arce's family filed a lawsuit seeking $5 million last year but will settle for $2 million

SP Breaking Graphic v6.png

 Graphic published on Tuesday, March 3, 2020.

Tempe City Council unanimously approved a $2 million settlement to the family of Antonio Arce, the 14 year old who was killed by Tempe police in January 2019. 

Arce was shot by police while running away. Arce was seen holding an airsoft gun, which police allegedly mistook for a weapon. The shooting garnered national attention and city-wide protests sprouted, calling for justice for the teenager.

The settlement comes almost a year after Arce's family filed a lawsuit asking for $5 million against the city and its police department, according to the Arizona Republic

The settlement waives all claims made against the City of Tempe and those involved in the lawsuit. That includes the now-former officer who shot Arce, Joseph Jaen, who resigned from the department shortly after the shooting.

During the city council meeting, Tempe Mayor Mark Mitchell said the city is settling because it recognizes that the officer who killed Arce was "out of line" and "wrong."

According to the settlement, Jaen was on duty responding to a call about a "suspicious pick-up truck parked in an alley." 

Body-camera footage obtained by the Arizona Republic shows Arce seated in the cab of the truck when Jaen called for his attention, failing to identify himself as police. 

Arce began to run. Jaen called for Arce to put his hands in the air, but he did not comply. Jaen then fired two rounds, and one bullet hit Arce's back shoulder. The teenager died at the scene, the settlement said.

Tempe Police Chief Sylvia Moir detailed that an internal investigation by the department found that Jaen had violated training and department policies, according to the Arizona Republic. Jaen did not face criminal charges for the incident.

ASU students attended two protests in early 2019 demanding justice for Arce’s death. The first protest was staged at the Tempe Police Department two days after his death, with his family in attendance, asking police to release an autopsy and body-camera footage of the incident, which police later complied with. 

The second protest, organized by multiple organizations, including Young Democratic Socialists of America at ASU and Tempe Against Police Violence, was staged two weeks later at a Tempe city hall meeting, where Tempe police showed Arce’s family body-camera footage of the incident. One ASU student was arrested at the demonstration along with three other protestors. 

Wyatt Myskow contributed to the reporting of this article

Reach the reporters at and and follow @ellieeborstt and @HorseySeven on Twitter.

Like The State Press on Facebook and follow @statepress on Twitter.

Jeffrey HorstDigital editor-in-chief

Jeffrey Horst is the digital editor-in-chief of The State Press. He previously served as the publication's sports editor and worked at Cronkite News and

Ellie BorstExecutive Editor 2021-22

Ellie Borst is the executive editor of The State Press, overseeing the publication and its four departments: online, magazine, multimedia and engagement. She plans to graduate in May 2022 with her master's in legal studies and got her bachelor's in journalism in 2021. Previous roles she has held since joining SP in 2018 include digital managing editor, magazine managing editor, community and culture desk editor, and arts and culture reporter.

Continue supporting student journalism and donate to The State Press today.

Subscribe to Pressing Matters



This website uses cookies to make your experience better and easier. By using this website you consent to our use of cookies. For more information, please see our Cookie Policy.